A question for Christians&Muslims who claim God invented HIV/AIDS to kill off homosexuals and other sinner?

If this is true, then why does God allow innocent parties to contract HIV and die of AIDS? (i.e. the faithful partners who contract HIV from a cheating partner, children who contract HIV in the womb).
If HIV/AIDS is a punishment for Homosexuality and fornication as some of you say, then why allow a faithful partner or unborn baby to be infected by it?

'R' - please re-read the question and answer it. What about the faithful partners and unborn infants?

I believe that bad things sometimes happen to good people. I don't believe that AIDS is a punishment from God anymore than cancer or diabetes are. Yes, sometimes people make risky choices and there are consequences. I make risky choices sometimes and have to deal with consequences, but I have compassion for those with HIV and would NEVER judge them by saying that they deserved what they got. That is a horrible and inhumane thing to do.

Anyone who thinks that is an incompassionate a$$hole

That's a load of bollox if I ever heard any

I love the story about how AIDS comes from people having sex with monkeys......If you knew someone who frequented having sex with monkeys, do you think they would ever go back to having sex with humans?

No one alive today is innocent first of all.
WE are all born sinners.
You have to understand that God weeps with you in the fact that Man-kind has made a HUGE mess of this thing we have here called earth. Man-kind has problems created by Man.
I however do not believe that God invented AIDS as a form of punishment.
However you look at this question there is no right answer. Just opinions. I can tell you with all the sincerity in my heart that God doesn't want this affliction on us anymore than we do.

The six Christians who actually believe that load of horse crap are too busy in make-up getting ready for their next televised hate-fest to be hanging out here wasting time with us blockheads.

Your question has its own answer. Why will god bother to do all this. We are destroying ourselves. If God created HIV, as you say why will an innocent suffer from the same. God has got nothing to do with this, though he does not play dice with the Creation. And another thing, with the increase of HIV, a single parent is also increasing balancing the factors. remember there is always a balance between Creation and dissolution. Negative factors are always balanced. God is the greatest equilibrium maker.

HIV is a virus not to kill off homosexuals. I think thats a sick view and any Christian or anyone really who thinks that should be decapitated and pissed on. Or maybe they themselves should ge HIV to teach them an important lesson, that on eath we are all humans and we are all people and each should be respected no matter what they believe or no matter their lifestyle choice.

You should ask GOD that question.

I don't happen to be one of those who claim that God 'invented' these diseases for that purpose, however I do say......If you plan to play the game, count on paying the price. Sometimes that includes hurting those that you love.

That would be a tough thing to live with, wouldn't it?

i'm christian. But it never cross my mind that God invented HIV/AIDS to kill off homosexuals. It's sin...because many non-homosexuals person also suffer HIV/AIDS even babies...
I'm sure you know this...God bless you...

The Lord did create everything, without any exceptions. Those who disobey the Almighty always have caused pain and suffering not only to themselves, but also to those who are close to them. Thus the path of obedience is good for one and all, and the path of disobedience is bad for one and all in some degree or another. If I am close to those who are openly disobeying the Almighty, my best option is to distance myself physically and emotionally from them.

If I do not do that, then in due time what is to befall them will also be shared by me or those around them. That is the nature of things. If someone wants to jump into the Niagra falls, if you tie yourself with them, or allow others to tie you to that person who wishes to jump in and you sit by without protesting or getting out of the ropes that are tying you to that person, so, you are also responsible for what is being done. If they are tying your innocent children in that rope as well, and you watch without acting, you are responsible for those children who can not act on their own.

If you live in a society that is unjust, and you do not act against those who are committing injustice, you will face injustice too in due time. It is just a matter of time. The instructions of the Almighty are to distance yourself as much and as quickly as possible from those who commit wrong doing, as punishment shall come to them in due time and others will also be affected because of their actions as we are all in the same boat, like it or not.

It all boils down to obedience and disobedience. Those who disobey and jump into Niagra falls will pay a price. You can not blame the existence of Niagra falls for what people do when there are clear signs all around that this is a dangerous area and be careful.

I hope some of this makes sense to you.

God created man in his own image and we created other unnecessary things thereby spoiling our life and the life of others. In fact we are slowly creating a "Dead World".
Let us go in tune with the Bible and the Commandments.
I assure you that we can change this world for the better.
But religion has manifested itself in different groups so then we all have to join hands to create a world without Sin and then without AIDS...

God warned us of having sex with animals or same sex partners get your facts together

Well, after re-reading your question I re-assure you that your
question is wrong .. I'm sorry .
The virus had not been INVENTED for killing... the virus has been there for millions of years ..... like all other dangerous
viruses ..... for the purpose of WARNING and SAVING human
beings! Show me HIV positive animals dying of AIDS !

The right question is : Who " invented " homosexuality ?
Ask a Buddhist , if you disagree with Christian&Muslim's Claim!
The first MAN who violated the CONTRACT, is responsible for all further contractors!!
"R" , Re-read it please! The first MAN who breached the
divine CONTRACT for heterosexuality ...(Multiply...!)fo He is
RESPONSIBLE for the whole tragedy !

Check out the story of King David and Bathsheeba, After David realised that he had sinned against God he cried out to God to have mercy on the child Bathsheeba was carrying, but God did not let that child live even though He had forgiven David.

What you need to realise is that sin does not just affect the parties involved, it affects all those around. Take divorce as an example, it's not only the spouses that are hurt but the children aunties, uncles, grandparents, friends etc.

There's no doubt about it, man has caused the problems that he has now, abortions are on the increase, sex is advertised without any care to our young children etc, there's so much lawlessness and God will not just sit by and let us sail through life without us facing the consequences of our own actions when we clearly disobey His word.

The bible says that the wages of sin are death.

This is ridiculous as HIV/AIDS are man-made diseases so they cannot have been made by God.

Why target the homosexuals only, if this is what these _ _ _ _ _ _ _ believe?

why not the murderers? paedophiles? teenagers? cheating husbands/wives?

It makes no sense!

Homosexuals are born that way. I only wonder how these people would feel if homosexuality was "the norm" and heterosexuals were thought of in this way. They should put themselves in the shoes of another and see that they are just ordinary people too.

We have no right to judge others here on earth, God is the only person who can judge, and by judging homosexuals in this way, these religions are being blasphemous as they are playing God.

If God had not wanted homosexuals in this world, he would have killed them in the womb or shortly after birth. After all, He is the only one with the right to give and take life so perhaps this isn't going against His plans at all!

I am a muslim and islam is against homosexuality like all other religions, but saying god invented aids to kill homosexuals is bullshit, nowhere in our religious scriptures does it say that.

what!!!!

Did you know God forbids Adultery?
He is against it for a reason. and its for your own good.
but some people choose Not to obey. In result, their punishment.

It is not only Christians and Muslims who believe that...We hindus believe that as well.....Homosexuality should be outlawed